User menu

Accès à distance ? S'identifier sur le proxy UCLouvain

Diagnosis of obstructive coronary artery disease using computed tomography angiography in patients with stable chest pain depending on clinical probability and in clinically important subgroups: meta-analysis of individual patient data.

Primary tabs

download
  • Open access
  • PDF
  • 662.38 K
Haase, Robert Schlattmann, Peter Gueret, Pascal Andreini, Daniele Pontone, Gianluca Gerber, Bernhard [UCL] COME-CCT Consortium

(eng) OBJECTIVE: To determine whether coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA) should be performed in patients with any clinical probability of coronary artery disease (CAD), and whether the diagnostic performance differs between subgroups of patients. DESIGN: Prospectively designed meta-analysis of individual patient data from prospective diagnostic accuracy studies. DATA SOURCES: Medline, Embase, and Web of Science for published studies. Unpublished studies were identified via direct contact with participating investigators. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES: Prospective diagnostic accuracy studies that compared coronary CTA with coronary angiography as the reference standard, using at least a 50% diameter reduction as a cutoff value for obstructive CAD. All patients needed to have a clinical indication for coronary angiography due to suspected CAD, and both tests had to be performed in all patients. Results had to be provided using 2×2 or 3×2 cross tabulations for the comparison of CTA with coronary angiography. Primary outcomes were the positive and negative predictive values of CTA as a function of clinical pretest probability of obstructive CAD, analysed by a generalised linear mixed model; calculations were performed including and excluding non-diagnostic CTA results. The no-treat/treat threshold model was used to determine the range of appropriate pretest probabilities for CTA. The threshold model was based on obtained post-test probabilities of less than 15% in case of negative CTA and above 50% in case of positive CTA. Sex, angina pectoris type, age, and number of computed tomography detector rows were used as clinical variables to analyse the diagnostic performance in relevant subgroups. RESULTS: Individual patient data from 5332 patients from 65 prospective diagnostic accuracy studies were retrieved. For a pretest probability range of 7-67%, the treat threshold of more than 50% and the no-treat threshold of less than 15% post-test probability were obtained using CTA. At a pretest probability of 7%, the positive predictive value of CTA was 50.9% (95% confidence interval 43.3% to 57.7%) and the negative predictive value of CTA was 97.8% (96.4% to 98.7%); corresponding values at a pretest probability of 67% were 82.7% (78.3% to 86.2%) and 85.0% (80.2% to 88.9%), respectively. The overall sensitivity of CTA was 95.2% (92.6% to 96.9%) and the specificity was 79.2% (74.9% to 82.9%). CTA using more than 64 detector rows was associated with a higher empirical sensitivity than CTA using up to 64 rows (93.4% v 86.5%, P=0.002) and specificity (84.4% v 72.6%, P<0.001). The area under the receiver-operating-characteristic curve for CTA was 0.897 (0.889 to 0.906), and the diagnostic performance of CTA was slightly lower in women than in with men (area under the curve 0.874 (0.858 to 0.890) v 0.907 (0.897 to 0.916), P<0.001). The diagnostic performance of CTA was slightly lower in patients older than 75 (0.864 (0.834 to 0.894), P=0.018 v all other age groups) and was not significantly influenced by angina pectoris type (typical angina 0.895 (0.873 to 0.917), atypical angina 0.898 (0.884 to 0.913), non-anginal chest pain 0.884 (0.870 to 0.899), other chest discomfort 0.915 (0.897 to 0.934)). CONCLUSIONS: In a no-treat/treat threshold model, the diagnosis of obstructive CAD using coronary CTA in patients with stable chest pain was most accurate when the clinical pretest probability was between 7% and 67%. Performance of CTA was not influenced by the angina pectoris type and was slightly higher in men and lower in older patients. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42012002780.

Document type Article de périodique (Journal article) – Article de recherche
Access type Accès libre
Publication date 2019
Language Anglais
Journal information "BMJ (Clinical research ed.)" - Vol. 365, no. 8209, p. l1945 [1-15] (2019)
Peer reviewed yes
Publisher British Medical Association ((United Kingdom) London)
issn 1468-5833
e-issn 1756-1833
Publication status Publié
Affiliations UCL - SSS/IREC/CARD - Pôle de recherche cardiovasculaire
UCL - (SLuc) Service de cardiologie
Links
  1. Diamond George A., Denton Timothy A., Berman Daniel S., Cohen Ishae, Prior Restraint: A Bayesian Perspective on the Optimization of Technology Utilization for Diagnosis of Coronary Artery Disease, 10.1016/s0002-9149(99)80809-1
  2. Leeflang Mariska M.G., Bossuyt Patrick M.M., Irwig Les, Diagnostic test accuracy may vary with prevalence: implications for evidence-based diagnosis, 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2008.04.007
  3. 2013 ESC guidelines on the management of stable coronary artery disease : The Task Force on the management of stable coronary artery disease of the European Society of Cardiology, 10.1093/eurheartj/eht296
  4. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Chest pain of recent onset: assessment and diagnosis. Secondary chest pain of recent onset: assessment and diagnosis 2016. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg95.
  5. Moschovitis Aris, Cook Stéphane, Meier Bernhard, Percutaneous coronary interventions in Europe in 2006, 10.4244/eijv6i2a31
  6. Patel Manesh R., Peterson Eric D., Dai David, Brennan J. Matthew, Redberg Rita F., Anderson H. Vernon, Brindis Ralph G., Douglas Pamela S., Low Diagnostic Yield of Elective Coronary Angiography, 10.1056/nejmoa0907272
  7. Schlattmann Peter, Schuetz Georg M., Dewey Marc, Influence of coronary artery disease prevalence on predictive values of coronary CT angiography: a meta-regression analysis, 10.1007/s00330-011-2142-2
  8. Dewey Marc, Rief Matthias, Martus Peter, Kendziora Benjamin, Feger Sarah, Dreger Henryk, Priem Sascha, Knebel Fabian, Böhm Marko, Schlattmann Peter, Hamm Bernd, Schönenberger Eva, Laule Michael, Zimmermann Elke, Evaluation of computed tomography in patients with atypical angina or chest pain clinically referred for invasive coronary angiography: randomised controlled trial, 10.1136/bmj.i5441
  9. , Coronary CT Angiography and 5-Year Risk of Myocardial Infarction, 10.1056/nejmoa1805971
  10. Patel Manesh R., Dai David, Hernandez Adrian F., Douglas Pamela S., Messenger John, Garratt Kirk N., Maddox Thomas M., Peterson Eric D., Roe Matthew T., Prevalence and predictors of nonobstructive coronary artery disease identified with coronary angiography in contemporary clinical practice, 10.1016/j.ahj.2014.03.001
  11. Schuetz Georg M, Schlattmann Peter, Achenbach Stephan, Budoff Matthew, Garcia Mario J, Roehle Robert, Pontone Gianluca, Meijboom Willem Bob, Andreini Daniele, Alkadhi Hatem, Honoris Lily, Bettencourt Nuno, Hausleiter Jörg, Leschka Sebastian, Gerber Bernhard L, Meijs Matthijs FL, Shabestari Abbas Arjmand, Sato Akira, Zimmermann Elke, Schoepf Uwe J, Diederichsen Axel, Halon David A, Mendoza-Rodriguez Vladimir, Hamdan Ashraf, Nørgaard Bjarne L, Brodoefel Harald, Øvrehus Kristian A, Jenkins Shona MM, Halvorsen Bjørn A, Rixe Johannes, Sheikh Mehraj, Langer Christoph, Martuscelli Eugenio, Romagnoli Andrea, Scholte Arthur JHA, Marcus Roy P, Ulimoen Geir R, Nieman Koen, Mickley Hans, Nikolaou Konstantin, Tardif Jean-Claude, Johnson Thorsten RC, Muraglia Simone, Chow Benjamin JW, Maintz David, Laule Michael, Dewey Marc, Individual patient data meta-analysis for the clinical assessment of coronary computed tomography angiography: protocol of the Collaborative Meta-Analysis of Cardiac CT (CoMe-CCT), 10.1186/2046-4053-2-13
  12. Hunink M.G. Myriam, Weinstein Milton C., Wittenberg Eve, Drummond Michael F., Pliskin Joseph S., Wong John B., Glasziou Paul P., Decision Making in Health and Medicine : Integrating Evidence and Values, ISBN:9781139506779, 10.1017/cbo9781139506779
  13. SOX HAROLD C., Diagnostic Decision: Probability Theory in the Use of Diagnostic Tests : An Introduction to Critical Study of the Literature, 10.7326/0003-4819-104-1-60
  14. Stewart Lesley A., Clarke Mike, Rovers Maroeska, Riley Richard D., Simmonds Mark, Stewart Gavin, Tierney Jayne F., Preferred Reporting Items for a Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Individual Participant Data : The PRISMA-IPD Statement, 10.1001/jama.2015.3656
  15. Whiting Penny, Rutjes Anne W.S., Reitsma Johannes B., Glas Afina S., Bossuyt Patrick M.M., Kleijnen Jos, Sources of Variation and Bias in Studies of Diagnostic Accuracy : A Systematic Review, 10.7326/0003-4819-140-3-200402030-00010
  16. Schuetz G. M., Schlattmann P., Dewey M., Use of 3x2 tables with an intention to diagnose approach to assess clinical performance of diagnostic tests: meta-analytical evaluation of coronary CT angiography studies, 10.1136/bmj.e6717
  17. Genders T. S. S., Steyerberg E. W., Alkadhi H., Leschka S., Desbiolles L., Nieman K., Galema T. W., Meijboom W. B., Mollet N. R., de Feyter P. J., Cademartiri F., Maffei E., Dewey M., Zimmermann E., Laule M., Pugliese F., Barbagallo R., Sinitsyn V., Bogaert J., Goetschalckx K., Schoepf U. J., Rowe G. W., Schuijf J. D., Bax J. J., de Graaf F. R., Knuuti J., Kajander S., van Mieghem C. A. G., Meijs M. F. L., Cramer M. J., Gopalan D., Feuchtner G., Friedrich G., Krestin G. P., Hunink M. G. M., , A clinical prediction rule for the diagnosis of coronary artery disease: validation, updating, and extension, 10.1093/eurheartj/ehr014
  18. Diamond George A., Forrester James S., Analysis of Probability as an Aid in the Clinical Diagnosis of Coronary-Artery Disease, 10.1056/nejm197906143002402
  19. Diamond George A., A clinically relevant classification of chest discomfort, 10.1016/s0735-1097(83)80093-x
  20. Diamond G A, Forrester J S, Hirsch M, Staniloff H M, Vas R, Berman D S, Swan H J, Application of conditional probability analysis to the clinical diagnosis of coronary artery disease., 10.1172/jci109776
  21. Schuetz Georg M., Meta-analysis: Noninvasive Coronary Angiography Using Computed Tomography Versus Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 10.7326/0003-4819-152-3-201002020-00008
  22. Ahmed I., Sutton A. J., Riley R. D., Assessment of publication bias, selection bias, and unavailable data in meta-analyses using individual participant data: a database survey, 10.1136/bmj.d7762
  23. Whiting Penny F., QUADAS-2: A Revised Tool for the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies, 10.7326/0003-4819-155-8-201110180-00009
  24. Coughlin Steven S., Trock Bruce, Criqui Michael H., Pickle Linda W., Browner Deirdre, Tefft Mariella C., The logistic modeling of sensitivity, specificity, and predictive value of a diagnostic test, 10.1016/0895-4356(92)90180-u
  25. Simmonds Mark C, Higgins Julian PT, A general framework for the use of logistic regression models in meta-analysis, 10.1177/0962280214534409
  26. Skrondal Anders, Rabe-Hesketh Sophia, Generalized Latent Variable Modeling : Multilevel, Longitudinal, and Structural Equation Models, ISBN:9780429205491, 10.1201/9780203489437
  27. Skrondal Anders, Rabe-Hesketh Sophia, Prediction in multilevel generalized linear models, 10.1111/j.1467-985x.2009.00587.x
  28. DeLong Elizabeth R., DeLong David M., Clarke-Pearson Daniel L., Comparing the Areas under Two or More Correlated Receiver Operating Characteristic Curves: A Nonparametric Approach, 10.2307/2531595
  29. Rücker Gerta, Schwarzer Guido, Carpenter James, Arcsine test for publication bias in meta-analyses with binary outcomes, 10.1002/sim.2971
  30. Leeflang Mariska M.G., Deeks Jonathan J., Rutjes Anne W.S., Reitsma Johannes B., Bossuyt Patrick M.M., Bivariate meta-analysis of predictive values of diagnostic tests can be an alternative to bivariate meta-analysis of sensitivity and specificity, 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2012.03.006
  31. Chu Haitao, Cole Stephen R., Bivariate meta-analysis of sensitivity and specificity with sparse data: a generalized linear mixed model approach, 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2006.06.011
  32. R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Secondary R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2017. http://www.R-project.org/.
  33. Bates D, Maechler M, Bolker B, et al. lme4: Linear mixed-effects models using Eigen and S4. R package version 1.1-7. 2014. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lme4/index.html.
  34. Schwarzer G. meta: Meta-Analysis with R. R package version 3.2-1. 2014. http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=meta.
  35. Robin Xavier, Turck Natacha, Hainard Alexandre, Tiberti Natalia, Lisacek Frédérique, Sanchez Jean-Charles, Müller Markus, pROC: an open-source package for R and S+ to analyze and compare ROC curves, 10.1186/1471-2105-12-77
  36. Length, J Stat Softw, 69, 1 (2016)
  37. Agatston Arthur S., Janowitz Warren R., Hildner Frank J., Zusmer Noel R., Viamonte Manuel, Detrano Robert, Quantification of coronary artery calcium using ultrafast computed tomography, 10.1016/0735-1097(90)90282-t
  38. Fihn Stephan D., Gardin Julius M., Abrams Jonathan, Berra Kathleen, Blankenship James C., Dallas Apostolos P., Douglas Pamela S., Foody JoAnne M., Gerber Thomas C., Hinderliter Alan L., King Spencer B., Kligfield Paul D., Krumholz Harlan M., Kwong Raymond Y.K., Lim Michael J., Linderbaum Jane A., Mack Michael J., Munger Mark A., Prager Richard L., Sabik Joseph F., Shaw Leslee J., Sikkema Joanna D., Smith Craig R., Smith Sidney C., Spertus John A., Williams Sankey V., 2012 ACCF/AHA/ACP/AATS/PCNA/SCAI/STS Guideline for the Diagnosis and Management of Patients With Stable Ischemic Heart Disease, 10.1016/j.jacc.2012.07.013
  39. Williams Michelle C., Hunter Amanda, Shah Anoop S.V., Assi Valentina, Lewis Stephanie, Smith Joel, Berry Colin, Boon Nicholas A., Clark Elizabeth, Flather Marcus, Forbes John, McLean Scott, Roditi Giles, van Beek Edwin J.R., Timmis Adam D., Newby David E., Use of Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography to Guide Management of Patients With Coronary Disease, 10.1016/j.jacc.2016.02.026
  40. Douglas Pamela S., Hoffmann Udo, Patel Manesh R., Mark Daniel B., Al-Khalidi Hussein R., Cavanaugh Brendan, Cole Jason, Dolor Rowena J., Fordyce Christopher B., Huang Megan, Khan Muhammad Akram, Kosinski Andrzej S., Krucoff Mitchell W., Malhotra Vinay, Picard Michael H., Udelson James E., Velazquez Eric J., Yow Eric, Cooper Lawton S., Lee Kerry L., Outcomes of Anatomical versus Functional Testing for Coronary Artery Disease, 10.1056/nejmoa1415516
  41. CT coronary angiography in patients with suspected angina due to coronary heart disease (SCOT-HEART): an open-label, parallel-group, multicentre trial, 10.1016/s0140-6736(15)60291-4
  42. Kaul Sanjay, Evaluating the Evidence for Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography as the Noninvasive Test of Choice for Patients With Stable Chest Pain, 10.1001/jamacardio.2018.4332
  43. Chang Hyuk-Jae, Lin Fay Y., Gebow Dan, An Hae Young, Andreini Daniele, Bathina Ravi, Baggiano Andrea, Beltrama Virginia, Cerci Rodrigo, Choi Eui-Young, Choi Jung-Hyun, Choi So-Yeon, Chung Namsik, Cole Jason, Doh Joon-Hyung, Ha Sang-Jin, Her Ae-Young, Kepka Cezary, Kim Jang-Young, Kim Jin-Won, Kim Sang-Wook, Kim Woong, Pontone Gianluca, Valeti Uma, Villines Todd C., Lu Yao, Kumar Amit, Cho Iksung, Danad Ibrahim, Han Donghee, Heo Ran, Lee Sang-Eun, Lee Ji Hyun, Park Hyung-Bok, Sung Ji-min, Leflang David, Zullo Joseph, Shaw Leslee J., Min James K., Selective Referral Using CCTA Versus Direct Referral for Individuals Referred to Invasive Coronary Angiography for Suspected CAD, 10.1016/j.jcmg.2018.09.018
  44. Napp Adriane E., , Haase Robert, Laule Michael, Schuetz Georg M., Rief Matthias, Dreger Henryk, Feuchtner Gudrun, Friedrich Guy, Špaček Miloslav, Suchánek Vojtěch, Fuglsang Kofoed Klaus, Engstroem Thomas, Schroeder Stephen, Drosch Tanja, Gutberlet Matthias, Woinke Michael, Maurovich-Horvat Pál, Merkely Béla, Donnelly Patrick, Ball Peter, Dodd Jonathan D., Quinn Martin, Saba Luca, Porcu Maurizio, Francone Marco, Mancone Massimo, Erglis Andrejs, Zvaigzne Ligita, Jankauskas Antanas, Sakalyte Gintare, Harań Tomasz, Ilnicka-Suckiel Malgorzata, Bettencourt Nuno, Gama-Ribeiro Vasco, Condrea Sebastian, Benedek Imre, Čemerlić Adjić Nada, Adjić Oto, Rodriguez-Palomares José, Garcia del Blanco Bruno, Roditi Giles, Berry Colin, Davis Gershan, Thwaite Erica, Knuuti Juhani, Pietilä Mikko, Kępka Cezary, Kruk Mariusz, Vidakovic Radosav, Neskovic Aleksandar N., Díez Ignacio, Lecumberri Iñigo, Geleijns Jacob, Kubiak Christine, Strenge-Hesse Anke, Do The-Hoang, Frömel Felix, Gutiérrez-Ibarluzea Iñaki, Benguria-Arrate Gaizka, Keiding Hans, Katzer Christoph, Müller-Nordhorn Jacqueline, Rieckmann Nina, Walther Mario, Schlattmann Peter, Dewey Marc, Computed tomography versus invasive coronary angiography: design and methods of the pragmatic randomised multicentre DISCHARGE trial, 10.1007/s00330-016-4620-z
  45. von Ballmoos Moritz Wyler, Haring Bernhard, Juillerat Pascal, Alkadhi Hatem, Meta-analysis: Diagnostic Performance of Low-Radiation-Dose Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography, 10.7326/0003-4819-154-6-201103150-00007
  46. Carr J. Jeffrey, Hendel Robert C., White Richard D., Patel Manesh R., Wolk Michael J., Bettmann Michael A., Douglas Pamela, Rybicki Frank J., Kramer Christopher M., Woodard Pamela K., Shaw Leslee J., Yucel E. Kent, 2013 Appropriate Utilization of Cardiovascular Imaging, 10.1016/j.jacr.2013.03.019
  47. Taylor, Circulation, 122, e525 (2010)
  48. Dewey Marc, Vavere Andrea L., Arbab-Zadeh Armin, Miller Julie M., Sara Leonardo, Cox Christopher, Gottlieb Ilan, Yoshioka Kunihiro, Paul Narinder, Hoe John, de Roos Albert, Lardo Albert C., Lima Joao A., Clouse Melvin E., Patient Characteristics as Predictors of Image Quality and Diagnostic Accuracy of MDCT Compared With Conventional Coronary Angiography for Detecting Coronary Artery Stenoses: CORE-64 Multicenter International Trial, 10.2214/ajr.09.2833
  49. Dharampal Anoeshka S., Papadopoulou Stella L., Rossi Alexia, Weustink Annick C., Mollet Nico R. A., Meijboom W. Bob, Neefjes Lisan A., Nieman Koen, Boersma Eric, de Feijter Pim J., Krestin Gabriel P., Computed tomography coronary angiography accuracy in women and men at low to intermediate risk of coronary artery disease, 10.1007/s00330-012-2503-5
  50. Maffei E., Martini C., Tedeschi C., Spagnolo P., Zuccarelli A., Arcadi T., Guaricci A., Seitun S., Weustink A., Mollet N., Cademartiri F., Diagnostic accuracy of 64-slice computed tomography coronary angiography in a large population of patients without revascularisation: registry data on the comparison between male and female population, 10.1007/s11547-011-0693-6
  51. Götberg Matthias, Cook Christopher M., Sen Sayan, Nijjer Sukhjinder, Escaned Javier, Davies Justin E., The Evolving Future of Instantaneous Wave-Free Ratio and Fractional Flow Reserve, 10.1016/j.jacc.2017.07.770
  52. Cheng Victor Y., Berman Daniel S., Rozanski Alan, Dunning Allison M., Achenbach Stephan, Al-Mallah Mouaz, Budoff Matthew J., Cademartiri Filippo, Callister Tracy Q., Chang Hyuk-Jae, Chinnaiyan Kavitha, Chow Benjamin J.W., Delago Augustin, Gomez Millie, Hadamitzky Martin, Hausleiter Jörg, Karlsberg Ronald P., Kaufmann Philipp, Lin Fay Y., Maffei Erica, Raff Gilbert L., Villines Todd C., Shaw Leslee J., Min James K., Performance of the Traditional Age, Sex, and Angina Typicality–Based Approach for Estimating Pretest Probability of Angiographically Significant Coronary Artery Disease in Patients Undergoing Coronary Computed Tomographic Angiography : Results From the Multinational Coronary CT Angiography Evaluation for Clinical Outcomes: An International Multicenter Registry (CONFIRM), 10.1161/circulationaha.111.039255
  53. Jensen Jesper M., Voss Mette, Hansen Vibeke B., Andersen Lone K., Johansen Peter B., Munkholm Henrik, Nørgaard Bjarne L., Risk stratification of patients suspected of coronary artery disease: Comparison of five different models, 10.1016/j.atherosclerosis.2011.11.027
  54. Nevitt Sarah J, Marson Anthony G, Davie Becky, Reynolds Sally, Williams Lisa, Smith Catrin Tudur, Exploring changes over time and characteristics associated with data retrieval across individual participant data meta-analyses: systematic review, 10.1136/bmj.j1390
Bibliographic reference Haase, Robert ; Schlattmann, Peter ; Gueret, Pascal ; Andreini, Daniele ; Pontone, Gianluca ; et. al. Diagnosis of obstructive coronary artery disease using computed tomography angiography in patients with stable chest pain depending on clinical probability and in clinically important subgroups: meta-analysis of individual patient data.. In: BMJ (Clinical research ed.), Vol. 365, no. 8209, p. l1945 [1-15] (2019)
Permanent URL http://hdl.handle.net/2078.1/216667