Scientific Opinion on the risk to plant health posed by Daktulosphaira vitifoliae (Fitch) in the EU territory, with the identification and evaluation of risk reduction options

Baker , Richard [Oxoford University, UK] Bragard, Claude [UCL] Candresse, Thierry [Institut national de la recherche agronomique] Gianni , Gilioli [University of Parma] Grégoire, Jean-Claude [UCL] Holb, Imre [Institute of Plant Protection, Budapest] Jeger, Michael John [Imperial College London, UK] Karadjova, Olia Evtimova [Institute of soil science, agrotechnologies and plant protection, Sofia, Bulgaria] Magnusson, Sven Christer [Bioforsk plant health, Norwegian Institute for agricultural and environmental research] Makowski, David [Institut national de la recherche agronomique] Manceau, Charles [Agence nationale de la sécurité sanitaire de l'alimentation, de l'environnement et du travail] Navajas, Maria [Institut national de la rercherche agronomique] Trond, Rafoss [Farsund municipality] Rossi, Vittorio [Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Piacenza, Italy] Schans, Jan [Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority] Schrader, Gritta [Julius Kuehn-Institut] Urek, Gregor [Agricultural institute of Slovenia, Ljubljana] van Lenteren, Johan Coert [Wageningen University] Vloutoglou, Irene [Benaki Phytopathological Institute] van der Werf, Wopke [Wageningen University] Winter, Stephan [Leibniz Institut DSMZ-German] et al.[show all]

The Panel on Plant Health conducted a pest risk assessment for the grapevine insect pest, Daktulosphaira vitifoliae (an aphid species commonly known as phylloxera), in the European Union, identified risk reduction options and evaluated the effectiveness of the phytosanitary measures listed in Council Directive 2000/29/EC. Entry was assessed as potentially very likely for plants intended for planting (although the pathway is closed by Article 15 of Annex III) and very unlikely for fruit for consumption because transport and transfer would be very difficult, even though phylloxera has a moderate likelihood of association with the pathway. Establishment is very likely as the pest is already very widespread in the risk assessment area, occurring almost everywhere Vitis plants are present. Successful eradication is very unlikely and small populations can persist undetected in the soil. Spread within the EU is considered to be very likely because there are no effective barriers, it can disperse up to a few kilometres aided by the wind and it can readily be moved long distances with planting material. Grafting with resistant rootstocks throughout the EU ensures that the production of fruit and plants for planting is rarely affected by phylloxera infestations and, if so, only at a limited level. The Panel considers that the IIAII measures for D. vitifoliae do not assist in preventing entry and are ineffective in preventing spread because detection is so difficult. Restricting movements of plants for planting to cuttings grafted on resistant rootstocks, in combination with treatments (e.g. particularly fungicides and hot water treatments), was found to be the most effective risk reduction option. Limitations in the Cyprus protected zone regulations were identified.