BACKGROUND: Recently the World Health Organization, Foodborne Disease Burden Epidemiology Reference Group (FERG) estimated that 31 foodborne diseases (FBDs) resulted in over 600 million illnesses and 420,000 deaths worldwide in 2010. Knowing the relative role importance of different foods as exposure routes for key hazards is critical to preventing illness. This study reports the findings of a structured expert elicitation providing globally comparable food source attribution estimates for 11 major FBDs in each of 14 world subregions. METHODS AND FINDINGS: We used Cooke's Classical Model to elicit and aggregate judgments of 73 international experts. Judgments were elicited from each expert individually and aggregated using both equal and performance weights. Performance weighted results are reported as they increased the informativeness of estimates, while retaining accuracy. We report measures of central tendency and uncertainty bounds on food source attribution estimate. For some pathogens we see relatively consistent food source attribution estimates across subregions of the world; for others there is substantial regional variation. For example, for non-typhoidal salmonellosis, pork was of minor importance compared to eggs and poultry meat in the American and African subregions, whereas in the European and Western Pacific subregions the importance of these three food sources were quite similar. Our regional results broadly agree with estimates from earlier European and North American food source attribution research. As in prior food source attribution research, we find relatively wide uncertainty bounds around our median estimates. CONCLUSIONS: We present the first worldwide estimates of the proportion of specific foodborne diseases attributable to specific food exposure routes. While we find substantial uncertainty around central tendency estimates, we believe these estimates provide the best currently available basis on which to link FBDs and specific foods in many parts of the world, providing guidance for policy actions to control FBDs.
Havelaar Arie H., Kirk Martyn D., Torgerson Paul R., Gibb Herman J., Hald Tine, Lake Robin J., Praet Nicolas, Bellinger David C., de Silva Nilanthi R., Gargouri Neyla, Speybroeck Niko, Cawthorne Amy, Mathers Colin, Stein Claudia, Angulo Frederick J., Devleesschauwer Brecht, , World Health Organization Global Estimates and Regional Comparisons of the Burden of Foodborne Disease in 2010, 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001923
World Health Organization. Food safety risk analysis: A guide for national food safety authorities. FAO Food and Nutrition Paper 87. 2006.
Pires Sara M., Evers Eric G., van Pelt Wilfrid, Ayers Tracy, Scallan Elaine, Angulo Frederick J., Havelaar Arie, Hald Tine, Attributing the Human Disease Burden of Foodborne Infections to Specific Sources, 10.1089/fpd.2008.0208
Batz Michael B., Doyle Michael P., Morris J. Glenn, Painter John, Singh Ruby, Tauxe Robert V., Taylor Michael R., Wong Danilo M.A. Lo Fo, , Attributing Illness to Food, 10.3201/eid1107.040634
Devleesschauwer Brecht, Haagsma Juanita A., Angulo Frederick J., Bellinger David C., Cole Dana, Döpfer Dörte, Fazil Aamir, Fèvre Eric M., Gibb Herman J., Hald Tine, Kirk Martyn D., Lake Robin J., Maertens de Noordhout Charline, Mathers Colin D., McDonald Scott A., Pires Sara M., Speybroeck Niko, Thomas M. Kate, Torgerson Paul R., Wu Felicia, Havelaar Arie H., Praet Nicolas, Methodological Framework for World Health Organization Estimates of the Global Burden of Foodborne Disease, 10.1371/journal.pone.0142498
Pires Sara M., Assessing the Applicability of Currently Available Methods for Attributing Foodborne Disease to Sources, Including Food and Food Commodities, 10.1089/fpd.2012.1134
Butler Ainslie J., Thomas M. Kate, Pintar Katarina D.M., Expert Elicitation as a Means to Attribute 28 Enteric Pathogens to Foodborne, Waterborne, Animal Contact, and Person-to-Person Transmission Routes in Canada, 10.1089/fpd.2014.1856
Davidson Valerie J., Ravel André, Nguyen To N., Fazil Aamir, Ruzante Juliana M., Food-Specific Attribution of Selected Gastrointestinal Illnesses: Estimates from a Canadian Expert Elicitation Survey, 10.1089/fpd.2010.0786
Ravel André, Davidson Valerie J, Ruzante Juliana M., Fazil Aamir, Foodborne Proportion of Gastrointestinal Illness: Estimates from a Canadian Expert Elicitation Survey, 10.1089/fpd.2010.0582
Havelaar Arie H., Galindo Ángela Vargas, Kurowicka Dorotha, Cooke Roger M., Attribution of Foodborne Pathogens Using Structured Expert Elicitation, 10.1089/fpd.2008.0115
HOFFMANN SANDRA, FISCHBECK PAUL, KRUPNICK ALAN, McWILLIAMS MICHAEL, Using Expert Elicitation To Link Foodborne Illnesses in the United States to Foods, 10.4315/0362-028x-70.5.1220
Van der Fels-Klerx H. J., Cooke Roger M., Nauta Maarten N., Goossens Louis H., Havelaar Arie H., A Structured Expert Judgment Study for a Model of Campylobacter Transmission During Broiler-Chicken Processing, 10.1111/j.0272-4332.2005.00571.x
VALLY H., GLASS K., FORD L., HALL G., KIRK M. D., SHADBOLT C., VEITCH M. G. K., FULLERTON K. E., MUSTO J., BECKER N., Evaluation of a structured expert elicitation estimating the proportion of illness acquired by foodborne transmission for nine enteric pathogens in Australia, 10.1017/s0950268815002435
PLOS collections. WHO estimates of the global burden of foodborne diseases. http://collections.plos.org/ferg2015. Accessed 28 Dec. 2016.
, Research Synthesis Methods in an Age of Globalized Risks: Lessons from the Global Burden of Foodborne Disease Expert Elicitation : Perspective, 10.1111/risa.12385
Hald Tine, Aspinall Willy, Devleesschauwer Brecht, Cooke Roger, Corrigan Tim, Havelaar Arie H., Gibb Herman J., Torgerson Paul R., Kirk Martyn D., Angulo Fred J., Lake Robin J., Speybroeck Niko, Hoffmann Sandra, World Health Organization Estimates of the Relative Contributions of Food to the Burden of Disease Due to Selected Foodborne Hazards: A Structured Expert Elicitation, 10.1371/journal.pone.0145839
Aspinall W. P., Cooke R. M., Havelaar A. H., Hoffmann S., Hald T., Evaluation of a Performance-Based Expert Elicitation: WHO Global Attribution of Foodborne Diseases, 10.1371/journal.pone.0149817
Ezzati Majid, Lopez Alan D, Rodgers Anthony, Vander Hoorn Stephen, Murray Christopher JL, Selected major risk factors and global and regional burden of disease, 10.1016/s0140-6736(02)11403-6
Pires Sara Monteiro, Vigre Håkan, Makela Pia, Hald Tine, Using Outbreak Data for Source Attribution of Human Salmonellosis and Campylobacteriosis in Europe, 10.1089/fpd.2010.0564
Painter John A., Ayers Tracy, Woodruff Rachel, Blanton Elizabeth, Perez Nytzia, Hoekstra Robert M., Griffin Patricia M., Braden Christopher, Recipes for Foodborne Outbreaks: A Scheme for Categorizing and Grouping Implicated Foods, 10.1089/fpd.2009.0350
De Waal CS, Barlow K, Alderton L, Jacobson MF. Outbreak alert. Center for Science in the Public Interest, Washington, DC. 2002:57.
WHO. 2017. “Summary of Capacity Development Work 2016–17.” Part V of Codex Document CX/CAC 17/40/18: MATTERS ARISING FROM FAO AND WHO: CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES. http://www.who.int/foodsafety/capacity/fos_capacity_2016-7.pdf?ua=1. Accessed July 12, 2017.
MA Burgman (2015)
R Cooke (1991)
W Aspinall, 64 (2013)
Tyshenko Michael G., ElSaadany Susie, Oraby Tamer, Darshan Shalu, Catford Angela, Aspinall Willy, Cooke Roger, Krewski Daniel, Expert judgement and re-elicitation for prion disease risk uncertainties, 10.1504/ijram.2012.047552
Shokouhi Milad, White Ryen, Yilmaz Emine, Anchoring and Adjustment in Relevance Estimation, 10.1145/2766462.2767841
R Atkinson, 1044 (2003)
JL Bamber, Climatic Change, 1 (2016)
Flandoli F., Giorgi E., Aspinall W.P., Neri A., Comparison of a new expert elicitation model with the Classical Model, equal weights and single experts, using a cross-validation technique, 10.1016/j.ress.2011.05.012
DE KNEGT L. V., PIRES S. M., HALD T., Attributing foodborne salmonellosis in humans to animal reservoirs in the European Union using a multi-country stochastic model, 10.1017/s0950268814001903
Painter John A., Hoekstra Robert M., Ayers Tracy, Tauxe Robert V., Braden Christopher R., Angulo Frederick J., Griffin Patricia M., Attribution of Foodborne Illnesses, Hospitalizations, and Deaths to Food Commodities by using Outbreak Data, United States, 1998–2008, 10.3201/eid1903.111866
Ebel Eric D., Williams Michael S., Cole Dana, Travis Curtis C., Klontz Karl C., Golden Neal J., Hoekstra Robert M., Comparing Characteristics of Sporadic and Outbreak-Associated Foodborne Illnesses, United States, 2004–2011, 10.3201/eid2207.150833
BATZ MICHAEL B., HOFFMANN SANDRA, MORRIS J. GLENN, Ranking the Disease Burden of 14 Pathogens in Food Sources in the United States Using Attribution Data from Outbreak Investigations and Expert Elicitation, 10.4315/0362-028x.jfp-11-418
E Scallan, Emerg Infect Dis, 17 (2011)
Bibliographic reference
Hoffmann, Sandra ; Devleesschauwer, Brecht ; Aspinall, Willy ; Cooke, Roger ; Corrigan, Tim ; et. al. Attribution of global foodborne disease to specific foods: Findings from a World Health Organization structured expert elicitation.. In: PLoS One, Vol. 12, no.9, p. e0183641 [1-26] (2017)
